The primary issue, since re-burning of crankcase blow-by was mandated by the EPA, is where are people going to empty the catch cans? On the ground at the gas station (like many diesel owners used to do with their water/fuel separator filters), down the sink drain, in a hole dug by the owner?The factory doesn't install one because "someone" will forget to empty it and you will have chocolate milk filling the intake manifold...And then things will go south after that.
It’s a problem.
Search YouTube & you will find some good explanations of why catch cans are needed. But, there are lots of variables in how they work on a particular engine & what type of catch can is ideal. If you don’t fully understand all the variables, you can do more harm than good.
Plus, if you live in an area where freezing temps are common, the blow-by can freeze, which can result in main seal blow-outs when crankcase pressure has no place to vent.
I thought I fully understood all the variables until I watched a particular video. The YouTuber talked about Hurricane engine intakes being pressurized whenever boost is generated (duh, of course). What happens when there is no vacuum? An improper catch can set-up can send the boost pressure back into the crankcase. Oops!
Bottom line: If you fully understand all the physics of your particular engine & select the correctly valved set-up & maintain it properly, there are some benefits. But, if you are asking why you might need one, you probably need to stay away,
Last edited:
