Did the rear diff diff fluid yesterday and made a rookie mistake. Maybe jinxed myself by asking this thread earlier this week if the gasket is reusable.
Anyways, I drained the old oil, definitely grey color, smelled bad, then started pumping new oil in with an Amazon hand pump that worked pretty well. BUT, the end of the tube had a black plastic nozzle with little “keepers” on the end. That got pushed into the diff too far and when I pulled the tube out, the plastic nozzle fell off INTO THE FUCKING DIFF! Damn it! Got new oil, tried to find a replacement gasket but apparently only one dealer in CA has it and it’s nowhere near me. So I pulled off the cover, removed the plastic nozzle from inside the diff, reinstalled, and filled back up.
So far so good. Lesson learned. 20 minute job turned into 2 and a half hours